Here’s the problem I’ve had with Indiana Jones ever since the tail credits rolled in Raiders of the Lost Ark.
Prior to those credits, Indy never blinked, and he never winked.
In Raiders of the Lost Ark, the guy was tough and dependable. The job needed done, and he was ready to spit sand to get it so. Covered with sweat, the man was reluctant as hell, but ready to put off crying to step into the path of the world’s worst flying gravel to put things to right. And he had fists that had seen some down-n-dirty back-alley fisticuffs.
But… ever since, he’s been a cartoon.
Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom caught some of the fascinating adventurous action of it all, but threw the dirty gravel out the window.
And Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade? Forget about it. What a piece of worthless nonsense. Spielberg and Lucas had by then decided that their gorgeous statue was so shiny it deserved to be laughed at.
WHAT?!!!!!
At this point - and the years that have passed are part of the fuel of the problem - I assume Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull will be as unwieldy as the title itself. As much as I want to revisit the glorious source, I have no faith that we’ll even touch the goodness that whooped our asses in 1981. If the course of history is any clue, this new movie will be as silly as can be.
I’m betting there will be in-jokes galore, referring to all three of the previous entries in the franchise. I bet Indy will have some chemistry with Cate Blanchett’s bad-ass soldier woman, but that such will be reduced to laughs based on the difference in their ages - e.g. she’ll hit on him, with some mention of how they might have hit it off 20 years ago, and he’ll make some jokey comment that makes fun of her youth and inexperience. I bet Short Round and/or Willie Scott makes an appearance, if only as an aside. There’ll be a couple of jokes that reflect Indy’s experiences in the previous episodes (e.g. the painfully obvious reference to the Ark of the Covenant in The Last Crusade). And this will not only corrupt the dramatic oomph of Raiders, it’ll all assume that Indiana Jones is the set-up for joke… after joke… after joke. Age will be the springboard for the punchline of almost every gag. And action and adventure will be secondary elements of the story, rather than in-your-face necessity.
You know, saving the world shouldn’t be funny. Raiders knew that. The spirit of adventure in that first movie was secondary to the seriousness of humanity’s relationship to the supernatural (that is, oh, say, GOD!), and anything that was funny along the way happened in the wake of the drama, rather than riding a surfboard at its head.
When I sit down in the theater to watch Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull, it will be with an open mind - with a “give me what you got” attitude - but man oh man, if I’m being honest, I gotta tell you, I don’t think it’s going to touch Raiders of the Lost Ark, even so much as to ask it for the time of day.